E1.18 - Simplifying and combining surds

E1.18 - Simplifying and combining surds

Some square roots cannot be written as terminating or recurring decimals. In this Extended lesson, you will keep them exact, simplify them by extracting square factors, combine matching surds and multiply surds without losing accuracy.

Extracting square factors

Can 72\sqrt{72} be written more simply without replacing it by a rounded decimal? A square factor gives the answer: 72=36×272=36\times2, so its square root contains a factor of 66.

Surd

A surd is an irrational root written in exact form, such as 2\sqrt2 or 7\sqrt7. Not every root is a surd: 49=7\sqrt{49}=7 is rational, and 0=0\sqrt0=0. The square-root symbol means the non-negative square root; 49\sqrt{49} is 77, not ±7\pm7.

Recall that squaring and taking the non-negative square root undo one another for non-negative numbers. Since 62=366^2=36, a factor of 3636 under a root becomes a factor of 66 outside it.

Splitting a product under a square root

ab=ab(a≥0, b≥0)\sqrt{ab}=\sqrt a\sqrt b\qquad(a\ge0,\ b\ge0)

Both sides are non-negative and their squares equal abab, which explains the rule. Negative numbers have no real square roots, so these conditions matter.

Not in the List of formulas: learn it.

Choose the largest square factor you can see. If you start with a smaller one, the method still works, but you may need another simplification.

Worked example 1: taking out a square factor

Question. Simplify 72\sqrt{72}.

Plan. Split 7272 into a square factor and the remaining factor.

72=36×2choose the square factor 36=362split the product=62take the square root of 36\begin{aligned} \sqrt{72}&=\sqrt{36\times2} &&\text{choose the square factor 36}\\ &=\sqrt{36}\sqrt2 &&\text{split the product}\\ &=6\sqrt2 &&\text{take the square root of 36} \end{aligned}

Answer. 626\sqrt2.

Check. (62)2=36×2=72(6\sqrt2)^2=36\times2=72, and the answer is positive, as required.

Change only the square factor from 3636 to 4949. The remaining surd stays the same.

Worked example 2: a different square factor

Question. Simplify 98\sqrt{98}.

Plan. Use 98=49×298=49\times2.

98=49×2expose a square factor=72take out the factor 7\begin{aligned} \sqrt{98}&=\sqrt{49\times2} &&\text{expose a square factor}\\ &=7\sqrt2 &&\text{take out the factor 7} \end{aligned}

Answer. 727\sqrt2.

Check. Its square is 49×2=9849\times2=98. Also, 9<98<109<\sqrt{98}<10, consistent with 727\sqrt2.

Watch out

36×2=362\sqrt{36\times2}=36\sqrt2 is wrong. The factor outside must be the square root of 3636, so it is 626\sqrt2. In simplest form, the number left under the square root has no square factor greater than 11.

Combining like surds

Three lots of 5\sqrt5 plus two lots of 5\sqrt5 make five lots of 5\sqrt5. The root is a fixed number; you are counting equal-sized quantities. Thus 35+25=553\sqrt5+2\sqrt5=5\sqrt5, just as three metres plus two metres make five metres.

Like surds

Like surds have the same root part after simplification. Their numerical coefficients can be added or subtracted. For example, 232\sqrt3 and 737\sqrt3 are like surds; 232\sqrt3 and 252\sqrt5 are not.

Simplify first: 12\sqrt{12} and 27\sqrt{27} look different, but both contain the root part 3\sqrt3. This is how you decide which terms can combine.

Worked example 3: reveal matching roots

Question. Simplify 50+18\sqrt{50}+\sqrt{18}.

Plan. Extract square factors, then add the coefficients of 2\sqrt2.

50+18=52+32use 25 and 9 as square factors=(5+3)2count equal root parts=82add the coefficients\begin{aligned} \sqrt{50}+\sqrt{18}&=5\sqrt2+3\sqrt2 &&\text{use 25 and 9 as square factors}\\ &=(5+3)\sqrt2 &&\text{count equal root parts}\\ &=8\sqrt2 &&\text{add the coefficients} \end{aligned}

Answer. 828\sqrt2.

Check. Subtract 18=32\sqrt{18}=3\sqrt2 from the result: 82−32=52=508\sqrt2-3\sqrt2=5\sqrt2=\sqrt{50}.

Keep the roots and change only addition to subtraction. The coefficients now subtract.

Worked example 4: the same roots, a subtraction

Question. Simplify 50−18\sqrt{50}-\sqrt{18}.

Plan. Use the same simplified forms and retain the subtraction sign.

50−18=52−32simplify each root=(5−3)2subtract matching quantities=22collect the coefficients\begin{aligned} \sqrt{50}-\sqrt{18}&=5\sqrt2-3\sqrt2 &&\text{simplify each root}\\ &=(5-3)\sqrt2 &&\text{subtract matching quantities}\\ &=2\sqrt2 &&\text{collect the coefficients} \end{aligned}

Answer. 222\sqrt2.

Check. Add back 323\sqrt2: 22+32=522\sqrt2+3\sqrt2=5\sqrt2, recovering the first term.

Some expressions cannot combine further. The exact answer 2+3\sqrt2+\sqrt3 stays as it is; there is no common root part. Likewise 23+5−3=3+52\sqrt3+5-\sqrt3=\sqrt3+5: combine the surds and leave the rational term separate.

Watch out

a+b=a+b\sqrt a+\sqrt b=\sqrt{a+b} is not a rule. For instance, 9+16=3+4=7\sqrt9+\sqrt{16}=3+4=7, whereas 9+16=5\sqrt{9+16}=5. Splitting a product works; splitting a sum this way does not.

Products of surds and exact answers

Multiplication uses a different decision from addition: the root parts do not need to match. Multiply the numerical factors together, multiply the roots using the product rule, then simplify.

For a non-negative number, a×a=a\sqrt a\times\sqrt a=a: that is the defining property of its square root. A product of irrational numbers can therefore be rational. For example, 2×2=2\sqrt2\times\sqrt2=2.

Worked example 5: a product that remains a surd

Question. Work out 23×62\sqrt3\times\sqrt6, giving your answer in simplest exact form.

Plan. Multiply the root parts, then extract a square factor.

23×6=218multiply the numbers under the roots=2×32use 18=9×2=62multiply the coefficients\begin{aligned} 2\sqrt3\times\sqrt6&=2\sqrt{18} &&\text{multiply the numbers under the roots}\\ &=2\times3\sqrt2 &&\text{use }18=9\times2\\ &=6\sqrt2 &&\text{multiply the coefficients} \end{aligned}

Answer. 626\sqrt2.

Check. The original positive product has square 4×3×6=724\times3\times6=72; the answer has square 36×2=7236\times2=72 too.

Change only the second root, from 6\sqrt6 to 12\sqrt{12}. The product under the root is now a square.

Worked example 6: a rational product

Question. Work out 23×122\sqrt3\times\sqrt{12}.

Plan. Combine the roots before taking the square root.

23×12=236multiply 3 by 12=2×636 is a square=12finish the multiplication\begin{aligned} 2\sqrt3\times\sqrt{12}&=2\sqrt{36} &&\text{multiply 3 by 12}\\ &=2\times6 &&\text{36 is a square}\\ &=12 &&\text{finish the multiplication} \end{aligned}

Answer. 1212.

Check. Alternatively, 12=23\sqrt{12}=2\sqrt3, so the product is 2×2×3=122\times2\times3=12.

An exact answer preserves the full value, such as 626\sqrt2. A decimal such as 8.498.49 is a rounded approximation. Use decimals for an estimate if helpful, but retain roots throughout working when an exact answer is requested.

Exam tip

“Simplify” requires the square factors to be extracted and any like surds combined. A decimal approximation does not replace an exact simplified surd.

Quick Recap

  • Extract square factors: their square roots become coefficients outside the root.
  • Simplify first, then combine coefficients of matching root parts.
  • Multiply non-negative root parts using ab=ab\sqrt a\sqrt b=\sqrt{ab}; multiplication can produce a rational answer.
  • The square-root symbol gives the non-negative root, and exact answers retain surds where needed.

The opening expression simplifies exactly to 72=62\sqrt{72}=6\sqrt2, without rounding any digits.