C1.10; E1.10 - Limits of rounded measurements

C1.10; E1.10 - Limits of rounded measurements

A rounded measurement stands for a range of possible values. You will find that range, identify its lower and upper bounds, and decide what the recorded measurement does and does not tell you.

Rounding intervals

A parcel's mass is recorded as 3.4 kg3.4\,\mathrm{kg}, correct to the nearest 0.1 kg0.1\,\mathrm{kg}. Could its actual mass be 3.44 kg3.44\,\mathrm{kg}? Yes: different masses can give the same rounded reading. How far can that uncertainty extend?

The neighbouring readings are 3.33.3, 3.43.4 and 3.53.5. The changeover points are halfway between them: 3.353.35 and 3.453.45. Using the usual rule that a halfway positive value rounds up, 3.353.35 rounds to 3.43.4, but 3.453.45 rounds to 3.53.5.

Rounding interval

A rounding interval contains all values which round to a stated value at the specified accuracy. For the positive readings here, whose intervals stay above zero, the boundaries are half a rounding unit below and above the recorded value. The lower boundary is included; the upper boundary is excluded.

The rounding unit here is 0.10.1, so half a rounding unit is 0.050.05, not 0.50.5. Any extra restriction on the quantity still applies: an actual length cannot be negative, even if a rounding calculation extends below zero.

[DIAGRAM: asset_name: The interval for a rounded mass; asset_slug: rounded_mass_interval; caption: Every mass from 3.35 kg up to but not including 3.45 kg rounds to 3.4 kg.; description: An exact number line from 3.30 to 3.50 kg. The interval from 3.35 to 3.45 is highlighted pale blue. A filled circle at 3.35 marks the included lower boundary and an open circle at 3.45 marks the excluded upper boundary. The recorded value 3.40 is marked midway between them.]
Every mass from 3.35 kg up to but not including 3.45 kg rounds to 3.4 kg.

Worked example 1: nearest centimetre

Question. A length is 27 cm27\,\mathrm{cm}, correct to the nearest centimetre. Write its rounding interval.

Plan. Go half a centimetre below and above the reading.

1÷2=0.5half the rounding unit27−0.5=26.5lower changeover27+0.5=27.5upper changeover\begin{aligned} 1\div2&=0.5 &&\text{half the rounding unit}\\ 27-0.5&=26.5 &&\text{lower changeover}\\ 27+0.5&=27.5 &&\text{upper changeover} \end{aligned}

Answer. The length is at least 26.5 cm26.5\,\mathrm{cm} and less than 27.5 cm27.5\,\mathrm{cm}.

Check. 26.526.5 rounds to 2727, while 27.527.5 rounds to 2828. A value just inside either boundary rounds to 2727.

Keep the recorded length the same, but change the precision of the measurement. That changes the uncertainty.

Worked example 2: nearest tenth of a centimetre

Question. A length is 27.0 cm27.0\,\mathrm{cm}, correct to the nearest 0.1 cm0.1\,\mathrm{cm}. Write its rounding interval.

Plan. Use half of 0.1 cm0.1\,\mathrm{cm} on either side.

0.1÷2=0.05half the new rounding unit27.0−0.05=26.95lower boundary27.0+0.05=27.05upper boundary\begin{aligned} 0.1\div2&=0.05 &&\text{half the new rounding unit}\\ 27.0-0.05&=26.95 &&\text{lower boundary}\\ 27.0+0.05&=27.05 &&\text{upper boundary} \end{aligned}

Answer. At least 26.95 cm26.95\,\mathrm{cm} and less than 27.05 cm27.05\,\mathrm{cm}.

Check. The interval has width 0.10 cm0.10\,\mathrm{cm}, one rounding unit, and its midpoint is 27.0 cm27.0\,\mathrm{cm}.

Watch out

The recorded value alone does not determine its bounds. 2727 to the nearest whole unit and 27.027.0 to one decimal place have equal values but different stated accuracies.

Lower and upper boundaries

The lower bound is the lower boundary of the possible values; the upper bound is the upper boundary. An upper bound is still called a bound even when the measurement cannot equal it. There is no greatest possible real value below an excluded boundary: you can always choose one closer to it.

If mm denotes the parcel's actual mass, the opening interval can be written 3.35≤m<3.453.35\le m<3.45, with mm measured in kilograms. Read this as “mm is at least 3.353.35, and is less than 3.453.45”. The symbol ≤\le includes equality; << excludes it.

For significant figures, first identify the place value of the last retained digit. That tells you the rounding unit. A number rounded to two significant figures does not always have the same uncertainty as another number rounded to two significant figures.

Worked example 3: two significant figures

Question. A distance is 460 m460\,\mathrm{m}, correct to two significant figures. Give its lower and upper bounds.

Plan. The last retained digit is in the tens column, so halve 10 m10\,\mathrm{m}.

10÷2=5half the rounding unit460−5=455lower bound460+5=465upper bound\begin{aligned} 10\div2&=5 &&\text{half the rounding unit}\\ 460-5&=455 &&\text{lower bound}\\ 460+5&=465 &&\text{upper bound} \end{aligned}

Answer. Lower bound 455 m455\,\mathrm{m}; upper bound 465 m465\,\mathrm{m}. The interval is 455≤d<465455\le d<465, for distance dd in metres.

Check. 455455 rounds to 460460 at two significant figures, but 465465 rounds to 470470.

Now make the distance ten times as large while keeping two significant figures. The rounding unit also becomes ten times as large.

Worked example 4: a different last place

Question. A distance is 4600 m4600\,\mathrm{m}, correct to two significant figures. Give its lower and upper bounds.

Plan. The last retained digit is now in the hundreds column.

100÷2=50half a hundred4600−50=4550lower bound4600+50=4650upper bound\begin{aligned} 100\div2&=50 &&\text{half a hundred}\\ 4600-50&=4550 &&\text{lower bound}\\ 4600+50&=4650 &&\text{upper bound} \end{aligned}

Answer. Lower bound 4550 m4550\,\mathrm{m}; upper bound 4650 m4650\,\mathrm{m}.

Check. The width is 100 m100\,\mathrm{m}, matching the rounding unit, and the recorded distance lies halfway between the bounds.

Watch out

An upper bound of 465465 is not 464.999464.999. That particular number lies inside the interval; values such as 464.9999464.9999 can lie closer to the boundary.

Interpreting measurement limits

A rounded reading tells you which values are possible, not which of them actually occurred. To test a proposed measurement, find the interval and compare it with both boundaries. Keep units consistent.

Worked example 5: a possible measurement

Question. A length is recorded as 8.2 m8.2\,\mathrm{m}, correct to the nearest 0.1 m0.1\,\mathrm{m}. Could the actual length be 8.249 m8.249\,\mathrm{m}?

Plan. Find the rounding interval and locate the proposed value.

8.2−0.05=8.15included lower boundary8.2+0.05=8.25excluded upper boundary8.15≤8.249<8.25the value lies inside\begin{aligned} 8.2-0.05&=8.15 &&\text{included lower boundary}\\ 8.2+0.05&=8.25 &&\text{excluded upper boundary}\\ 8.15&\le8.249<8.25 &&\text{the value lies inside} \end{aligned}

Answer. Yes, 8.249 m8.249\,\mathrm{m} is possible.

Check. Rounding 8.2498.249 to one decimal place gives 8.28.2.

Move only the proposed value to the upper boundary. The conclusion changes even though the movement is tiny.

Worked example 6: exactly on the upper boundary

Question. With the same recorded length and accuracy, could the actual length be 8.250 m8.250\,\mathrm{m}?

Plan. Compare the proposed value with the excluded boundary.

8.250=8.25the upper boundary8.250≮8.25strict inequality fails\begin{aligned} 8.250&=8.25 &&\text{the upper boundary}\\ 8.250&\not<8.25 &&\text{strict inequality fails} \end{aligned}

Answer. No, 8.250 m8.250\,\mathrm{m} is excluded.

Check. 8.2508.250 rounds to 8.38.3, not 8.28.2, to one decimal place.

This explains the parcel at the start: 3.44 kg3.44\,\mathrm{kg} is possible, but the recorded 3.4 kg3.4\,\mathrm{kg} is not an exact mass. A count of exactly 1212 objects is different: it is exact, so do not invent a half-unit interval unless the count is stated to have been rounded.

Key idea

The stated accuracy supplies the uncertainty. A rounded value identifies an interval; it does not reveal the actual measurement within it.

Quick Recap

  • Identify the rounding unit, then take half of it on either side of the recorded value.
  • For the positive rounded measurements here, include the lower boundary and exclude the upper boundary.
  • Significant figures require attention to the place value of the last retained digit.
  • Bounds limit possible values; they do not give the actual measurement.

The parcel can have mass 3.44 kg3.44\,\mathrm{kg}: every mass from 3.35 kg3.35\,\mathrm{kg} up to but not including 3.45 kg3.45\,\mathrm{kg} rounds to 3.4 kg3.4\,\mathrm{kg}.