2Q - The presidential election of 1960 and reasons for Kennedy’s victory
Kennedy promised national renewal, but won a remarkably close election and faced a Congress that could obstruct him. Learn why he defeated Nixon, how his administration worked and why the New Frontier produced both achievements and unfinished promises.
Winning a close election
The 1960 contest offered a choice between Republican continuity and Democratic renewal rather than between a Cold War supporter and an opponent. Richard Nixon had eight years' experience as Eisenhower's Vice-President. John F. Kennedy, a Massachusetts senator aged 43, argued that the United States needed more energetic leadership to overcome economic slowdown and Soviet challenges. The recession of 1960 weakened a Republican appeal based on prosperity. Kennedy's claim that America faced a dangerous missile gap made apparent complacency a national-security issue, although the supposed Soviet advantage in missile numbers was misleading.
Kennedy's Catholicism was both an obstacle and a source of support. Some Protestant voters feared that a Catholic president would follow the Pope's instructions. His victory in the largely Protestant West Virginia Democratic primary helped demonstrate that he could win beyond Catholic communities. In September he told Protestant ministers in Houston that his public decisions would follow the national interest and the separation of church and state. This addressed the objection without abandoning his faith. Catholic voters, especially in urban industrial states, supplied an important part of his coalition. Kennedy's Houston address.
Four televised debates brought the candidates into voters' homes. In the first, Kennedy appeared composed and presidential; Nixon, recovering from illness, appeared less confident on screen. Television helped a relatively unfamiliar challenger pass the credibility test, but it did not create his party organisation or erase Nixon's experience. Claims that radio listeners uniformly preferred Nixon are too uncertain to use as decisive evidence. In October Kennedy's sympathetic call to Coretta Scott King after her husband's arrest, and Robert Kennedy's intervention over his release, helped strengthen Black electoral support. Lyndon Johnson, his Texan running mate, helped reassure southern Democrats.
Kennedy won 303 electoral votes to Nixon's 219, with 15 going to Harry Byrd. The popular-vote margin was about 0.17 percentage points: the Electoral College made a tiny national lead into a clearer institutional victory. Democratic urban organisation, labour support, Catholic and Black voters, Johnson's southern appeal, economic conditions and Kennedy's campaign image interacted. Electoral arithmetic makes a single-cause explanation particularly weak. National Archives election results, JFK Library campaign collection.
People and presidential style
Kennedy presented his administration as youthful, expert and capable of solving difficult problems. His wartime naval service reinforced the image of courage, while his family wealth and connections supported a highly organised political career. Jacqueline Kennedy's cultural activities and restoration of the White House added glamour and an image of intellectual sophistication. This encouraged confidence in the presidency, but public presentation should be distinguished from legislative effectiveness.
Robert Kennedy, appointed Attorney General, was both a close personal adviser and head of the Justice Department. Robert McNamara, previously a Ford executive, became Secretary of Defense and brought an emphasis on management and quantitative analysis. Dean Rusk, Secretary of State, represented experienced Cold War diplomacy. McGeorge Bundy coordinated national-security advice from the White House, and Theodore Sorensen helped shape speeches and policy arguments. These roles mattered: expert advice widened presidential capacity but advisers could share assumptions about containment and underestimate political resistance in countries such as Vietnam.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account