2B - Filling the political vacuum: the rule of Richard of York as Protector of England
Learn how York tried to provide government when Henry VI could not exercise effective leadership. Distinguish his earlier protectorships from the settlement of 1460, then assess why legal authority did not secure obedience throughout the kingdom.
What the Protector could do
A political vacuum meant uncertainty about effective leadership, rather than the disappearance of courts, officials or all government. During Henry’s incapacity, routine administration continued, but difficult decisions about appointments, law and order and disputes among great lords required a recognised authority. York’s protectorship offered a way to supply that authority while retaining Henry as king.
Protector of the realm
A person entrusted with governing and defending the realm when the king could not provide effective leadership. The office did not itself confer the crown or an unconditional right to rule permanently.
York’s first protectorship began in March 1454 during Henry’s incapacity. His second ran from November 1455 to February 1456, after the first Battle of St Albans and renewed difficulties in royal government. These appointments must be kept distinct from York’s position after the Act of Accord in 1460. The circumstances and succession question had changed by then.
As Protector, York worked through the royal council and existing offices. Appointing Salisbury as chancellor during the first protectorate placed a trusted ally in a central post. Royal government remained a partnership involving the council and great lords, so York needed their acceptance. His authority was stronger than that of a private critic but narrower than kingship. Once Henry resumed effective rule, the justification for the temporary office weakened, leaving York’s position vulnerable.
Government and the problem of order
York’s task as Protector included maintaining order where powerful affinities threatened it. In 1454 the Percy–Neville feud in the north required intervention. In the second protectorate, violence involving the Earl of Devon and the Bonville interest in the south-west illustrated the need for a government able to act against disorder. A protector’s success had to be measured against these practical problems, as well as against his ability to obtain offices for allies.
The office created a dilemma. York needed trusted men to carry out policy, but his dependence on the Nevilles made enemies doubt that his arbitration would be impartial. Removing Somerset and changing officials could be justified as reform, yet also advanced York’s faction. A government that appeared to offer justice only to one group risked reproducing the grievance it was supposed to resolve.
Nor could a brief protectorate remove the Crown’s long-standing financial difficulties. Restoring order and restraining powerful men required resources and cooperation. Henry’s recovery could reverse York’s appointments before the new administration became secure. When the second protectorship ended in 1456, York again lost the executive position that had enabled him to address problems directly.
This explains the difference between holding office and settling government. York could exercise lawful authority and intervene in disputes, but that did not create agreement that his opponents would remain safe if he stayed influential or that he would remain safe if Henry’s favourites returned. Without such agreement, a change of office threatened to become another change of factional domination.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account