2D - The re-establishment of the Church of England: Elizabeth’s religious beliefs and aims
The 1559 settlement created a Protestant national Church through royal authority, parliamentary law and prescribed worship. Learn what Elizabeth sought, how the legislation was secured, and how the Prayer Book combined a clear change of direction with limited accommodation.
Elizabeth's beliefs and aims
Elizabeth's policy restored a Church independent of Rome and based on Protestant worship, but her preferences were more ceremonially conservative than those of some reformers. Her precise inner convictions cannot be recovered simply from every political choice. The evidence of policy and personal practice nevertheless places her within the Protestant restoration, rather than identifying her as a Catholic whose only concern was convenience.
She valued vernacular religious instruction and royal control of the Church. She also retained a taste for ceremonial and music, and disliked challenges to religious order. A Protestant ruler could regard some ceremony as legitimate while rejecting papal jurisdiction and Catholic Eucharistic doctrine. These positions were compatible even if more radical reformers found them unsatisfactory.
Her objectives included religious reform, political obedience and a durable succession to the lawful crown. Recognition of papal authority was particularly difficult for a queen whose legitimacy rested on Henry VIII's marriage to Anne Boleyn, which Rome had not accepted. Establishing the crown's ecclesiastical jurisdiction therefore had dynastic as well as religious significance.
Elizabeth also needed to prevent divisions from paralysing government. Many subjects were accustomed to Catholic worship; returning Protestants wanted reform; Catholic neighbours could exploit disorder. A public form of worship that enough clergy and subjects would use offered a practical route to stability. This aim involved managed conformity, rather than modern freedom to choose among separate public denominations.
Religious uniformity
A legally prescribed common form of public worship. Uniform practice does not necessarily imply identical private belief among everyone who participates.
The settlement should therefore be assessed on more than one criterion. It could establish a clear legal authority and a workable liturgy without resolving every theological disagreement. Recognising political calculation does not require assuming that Elizabeth lacked religious belief.
Parliament and the Act of Supremacy
Elizabeth's first Parliament met in 1559 and converted the crown's objectives into statute. Legislation mattered because earlier religious settlements had themselves been established by law. A lasting change needed to replace Marian provisions and supply a legal basis for jurisdiction and worship, rather than rely solely on temporary proclamations.
The process was contested, especially in the Lords, where Catholic bishops opposed the restoration. Debate and revisions separated the question of supremacy from prescribed worship. The Act of Supremacy and Act of Uniformity received royal assent on 8 May 1559. The existence of opposition and negotiated wording demonstrates that Parliament was an important mechanism and obstacle, not simply an audience for a predetermined royal command.
The Act of Supremacy abolished foreign ecclesiastical jurisdiction and restored it to the crown. Elizabeth became Supreme Governor, rather than using Henry VIII's title of Supreme Head. The revised title reduced objections from people who regarded Christ as the Church's only head, as well as concerns about a woman claiming spiritual headship. It did not leave the pope in control: the crown still possessed decisive governing authority over the English Church.
The oath of supremacy required ecclesiastical and relevant civil officeholders to recognise that authority. Refusal could lead to removal from office; repeated offences under the legislation attracted more severe sanctions. Most Marian bishops would not accept the new order and were deprived. Anthony Kitchin, bishop of Llandaff, conformed. A new Protestant episcopate, including Matthew Parker as archbishop of Canterbury, supplied the leadership needed for enforcement.
Royal authority could also operate through commissioners empowered to investigate ecclesiastical matters. The statute therefore changed both the source of jurisdiction and the means by which it could be exercised. Retaining bishops did not amount to retaining Rome: episcopal government now operated under the crown in a reformed Church.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account