2D - Religious divisions on Elizabeth’s accession: Catholics
Elizabeth inherited a Catholic Church, surviving Protestant networks and a costly war in November 1558. Learn why neither Catholics nor Protestants formed a single united bloc, and why peace with France mattered to the prospects of religious change.
The Catholic inheritance
Elizabeth's accession did not immediately change England's religion. Mary had restored papal authority and the Mass, and those arrangements remained the legal starting point until a new settlement was enacted. The bishops and much of the parish clergy had served the Marian Church. Many communities had invested in the recovery of traditional worship, making Catholicism an established institution and a living attachment rather than merely the policy of a dead queen.
Catholic supporters nevertheless had different priorities. Bishops defended the doctrinal and institutional authority of their Church. Some nobles and gentry combined Catholic faith with loyalty to the Tudor succession. Ordinary worshippers might be attached to the Mass and familiar parish practices without possessing the same understanding of jurisdiction as a bishop. How each group responded to reform depended partly on what it believed was being threatened.
Mary's death therefore did not produce an immediate national Catholic rising against Elizabeth. Many accepted her hereditary right and hoped that she would preserve some or all of Catholic worship. Others were prepared to obey lawful authority while retaining their own beliefs. Political loyalty and religious agreement could coexist, but they could also pull in different directions.
Catholic strength created a practical obstacle to change. The crown needed clergy to serve parishes and nobles and magistrates to maintain order. Removing every conservative officeholder would have damaged the administrative machinery on which the government depended. In Parliament, the bishops' position in the Lords would give organised Catholic opposition a direct role in the legislative process.
Assessing this inheritance requires care about scale. The prominence of Protestant martyrs demonstrates committed Protestant resistance under Mary, but it does not make all surviving parishioners Protestant. Equally, the legal restoration of Catholicism does not prove universal Catholic conviction. Elizabeth inherited both public institutions and a varied population whose beliefs were not fully recorded.
Returning Protestant exiles
Protestant exiles had preserved religious communities abroad during Mary's reign, and Elizabeth's accession offered them the prospect of return. These émigrés were religious refugees rather than a single organisation. Their experience of persecution encouraged a determination to prevent another Catholic restoration, while their Continental experience gave them different models for the Church that should replace it.
Returning clergy supplied valuable personnel. Men such as Edmund Grindal, John Jewel and Richard Cox would occupy important positions in the Elizabethan Church. Their education, preaching and connections could help establish Protestant ministry where Mary had removed reformers. Exiles therefore mattered as administrators and teachers as well as as voices demanding change.
Not all had experienced the same form of Protestantism. Communities in Strasbourg, Zurich, Frankfurt and Geneva encountered different approaches to worship, discipline and ecclesiastical organisation. Some defended the Edwardian Prayer Book as a suitable English order. Others wanted worship stripped more thoroughly of practices they associated with the Catholic Church.
The Geneva Bible, published in 1560 by exiles associated with Geneva, illustrates a further consequence of migration. It combined an English biblical text with explanatory material and could shape reading beyond the original exile community. It belongs to the consequences of exile and return; it was not already a published resource at Elizabeth's accession in 1558.
Elizabeth had reasons to welcome Protestant expertise without accepting every exilic political argument. John Knox's attack on female monarchy in The First Blast of the Trumpet against the Monstrous Regiment of Women in 1558 had been directed against Catholic female rulers, but its principle also offended the new English queen. A shared opposition to Rome did not automatically make every reformer an acceptable royal ally.
Exile preserved people, books and networks, but also widened disagreement over what a Protestant English Church should become.
Divisions within Protestantism
Those who supported a Protestant restoration agreed on some fundamental changes without agreeing on its final form. They rejected papal jurisdiction and wanted the Bible and reformed teaching to guide the Church. Their disagreements concerned the extent to which existing ceremonial and institutions could be retained consistently with that purpose.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account