2D - The restoration of Papal Authority: the second Parliament and the restoration of Papal Authority and Catholic doctrine
England's return to Rome depended on negotiation as well as Mary's religious conviction. Learn the sequence of parliamentary restoration, the revival of Catholic doctrine, Mary's reforming work and the limits of the Church she rebuilt.
Parliament and reconciliation with Rome
The return to Rome took place in stages, and the parliamentary chronology must be kept clear. Mary's first Parliament in autumn 1553 repealed Edward VI's religious laws. Her second Parliament in April–May 1554 confirmed the Spanish marriage arrangements. Her third Parliament, meeting from November 1554 to January 1555, carried through reconciliation with Rome and the repeal of the anti-papal legislation.
Cardinal Reginald Pole was the pope's legate: an authorised representative empowered to reconcile England to Rome. His family had suffered under Henry VIII, and his earlier attainder had made him legally a traitor. Parliament reversed that attainder on 22 November 1554, before Pole presided over the realm's public reconciliation to Rome on 30 November. Restoring his legal standing enabled him to carry out that public mission; it was a separate step from repealing the realm's anti-papal laws.
The more difficult negotiation concerned former Church land. The purchasers wanted assurance that papal reconciliation would not undo their titles. Mary could restore some property still under crown control, but a wholesale demand for restitution threatened the support of influential nobles and MPs. Papal acceptance of the property settlement removed that obstacle. Religious reconciliation thus depended on protecting an important material consequence of the break with Rome.
In late November 1554, Parliament sought reconciliation and Pole pronounced absolution. The subsequent repeal legislation, completed in January 1555, removed the statutory basis of the Henrician schism and restored papal jurisdiction. Public ceremony, spiritual reconciliation and parliamentary law were related, but they were not identical acts taking place at the same moment.
| Stage | Principal result | What remained to be done |
|---|---|---|
| First Parliament, 1553 | Edwardian religious laws repealed | End the Henrician separation from Rome |
| Second Parliament, spring 1554 | Marriage settlement approved | Resolve reconciliation and property questions |
| Third Parliament, 1554–1555 | Reconciliation and repeal of anti-papal laws | Restore Catholic teaching and practice throughout the Church |
Catholic doctrine and worship
Catholic restoration changed what happened in parish churches and what clergy were expected to teach. The Latin Mass displaced the Edwardian English Communion service. Altars, vestments and other furnishings returned where they could be obtained. Catholics understood the Eucharist through transubstantiation: the bread and wine became Christ's body and blood while their outward appearances remained. This doctrine differed fundamentally from the rejection of transubstantiation in Edwardian reform.
The restored Church affirmed seven sacraments, the sacramental role of the priesthood and practices associated with confession and penance. Belief in purgatory and prayers for the dead also regained official standing. These were connected elements of religious life. The Mass, priestly authority and intercession for the dead formed a system through which people sought spiritual help, rather than a collection of decorative ceremonies.
Clerical marriage presented a particularly direct conflict between successive regimes. Married priests were required to separate from their wives if they were to remain in ministry, and many lost their livings. Edwardian bishops were deprived or imprisoned, while conservative bishops such as Bonner returned to office. These changes restored Catholic authority at the top of the Church but also created local disruption and a need for replacement ministers.
Legal restoration did not guarantee uniform practice immediately. A parish could hear Mass again before it could replace all the religious objects sold during Edward's reign. An outwardly conforming worshipper might still hold Protestant beliefs. Conversely, parish expenditure on restored furniture could reflect a real attachment to Catholic worship rather than fear alone. Laws establish what was commanded; local records help show what was done.
Mary restored a Catholic framework of jurisdiction, doctrine and worship. Each needs separate evidence when judging how completely restoration reached ordinary believers.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account