1.02c - Simultaneous equations and intersections

1.02c - Simultaneous equations and intersections

Two equations can describe the same pair of unknowns, but only their common solutions satisfy both. Learn elimination and substitution, handle brackets and fractions, and explain why a line and a quadratic curve can meet twice, once or not at all.

Eliminating a variable

Can two perfectly valid equations have no common solution? The equations x+y=2x+y=2 and 2x+2y=52x+2y=5 do: doubling the first would require 2x+2y=42x+2y=4, which cannot also equal 55. We will connect that algebraic clash to the graphs, then see how a quadratic changes the possibilities.

You already know

Multiplying an equation by a non-zero constant preserves its solutions. Substituting a value back into an equation checks whether it satisfies that equation.

The important word is “both”. Satisfying just one equation is not enough.

Simultaneous solution

A simultaneous solution is a set of values satisfying every equation in a system at once. For two unknowns, give an ordered pair (x,y)(x,y). A linear equation has no products or powers of unknowns beyond the first power: 2x+3y=132x+3y=13 is linear; xy=13xy=13 is not.

Elimination removes one variable by adding or subtracting equations with matching coefficients. Keep an equation for back-substitution: the new equation alone usually describes many pairs.

Worked example 1: adding opposite coefficients

Question. Solve 2x+3y=132x+3y=13 and 3x−2y=03x-2y=0.

Plan. Make the coefficients of yy opposite, add, then recover yy.

4x+6y=26multiply the first equation by 29x−6y=0multiply the second by 313x=26add to eliminate yx=2,y=3solve, then substitute into 2x+3y=13\begin{aligned} 4x+6y&=26 &&\text{multiply the first equation by 2}\\ 9x-6y&=0 &&\text{multiply the second by 3}\\ 13x&=26 &&\text{add to eliminate }y\\ x&=2,\qquad y=3 &&\text{solve, then substitute into }2x+3y=13 \end{aligned}

Why this step? Opposite coefficients cancel on addition, leaving an equation in one unknown.

Answer. (x,y)=(2,3)(x,y)=(2,3).

Check. 2(2)+3(3)=132(2)+3(3)=13 and 3(2)−2(3)=03(2)-2(3)=0.

Change the second equation so the matched coefficients have the same sign. Subtract rather than add.

Worked example 2: subtracting matching coefficients

Question. Solve 2x+3y=132x+3y=13 and 3x+2y=123x+2y=12.

Plan. Match the positive coefficients of yy, subtract and back-substitute.

4x+6y=26first equation times 29x+6y=36second equation times 35x=10second new equation minus firstx=2,y=3solve and recover y\begin{aligned} 4x+6y&=26 &&\text{first equation times 2}\\ 9x+6y&=36 &&\text{second equation times 3}\\ 5x&=10 &&\text{second new equation minus first}\\ x&=2,\qquad y=3 &&\text{solve and recover }y \end{aligned}

Why this step? Subtraction cancels equal coefficients. Addition would double them instead.

Answer. (x,y)=(2,3)(x,y)=(2,3).

Check. 4+9=134+9=13 and 6+6=126+6=12.

A surprising boundary case: changing the opening system's second right side from 55 to 44 changes no solutions into infinitely many. Both equations then describe y=2−xy=2-x; every point on that line works. A contradiction such as 0=10=1 means no solution; an identity such as 0=00=0 means the two equations have supplied the same condition, not that x=y=0x=y=0.

Watch out

Wrong: multiply 2x+3y=132x+3y=13 by 22 to get 4x+6y=134x+6y=13. The right side must also double: 4x+6y=264x+6y=26.

Try a system whose coefficients already cancel.

Substitution and fractional equations

Substitution replaces a variable with an equal expression from another equation. If a variable already has coefficient 11, this can be quicker than matching coefficients.

Substituting an equal expression

If y=g(x)y=\mathrm g(x), then solving it with ax+by=cax+by=c reduces to

ax+bg(x)=c,ax+b\mathrm g(x)=c,

followed by y=g(x)y=\mathrm g(x), with the given domains retained.

Not in the formula sheet: learn it.

Brackets protect the whole substituted expression, especially after a minus sign.

Worked example 3: a ready-made substitution

Question. Solve y=2x−1y=2x-1 and 3x+y=143x+y=14.

Plan. Replace yy in the second equation, solve for xx, then recover yy.

3x+(2x−1)=14substitute for y5x=15collect termsx=3,y=5solve and substitute back\begin{aligned} 3x+(2x-1)&=14 &&\text{substitute for }y\\ 5x&=15 &&\text{collect terms}\\ x&=3,\qquad y=5 &&\text{solve and substitute back} \end{aligned}

Why this step? Each common solution has y=2x−1y=2x-1, so replacing yy by that expression preserves the condition.

Answer. (x,y)=(3,5)(x,y)=(3,5).

Check. 5=2(3)−15=2(3)-1 and 3(3)+5=143(3)+5=14.

The next system changes the presentation: fractions and brackets hide an equally simple substitution. Simplify each whole equation first.

Worked example 4: clearing fractions before substituting

Question. Solve x+2y3=3\dfrac{x+2y}{3}=3 and 2(x−y)=62(x-y)=6.

Plan. Clear the constant denominator and bracket coefficient, then express xx in terms of yy.

x+2y=9,x−y=3simplify each equationx=y+3rearrange the second(y+3)+2y=9substitute into the firsty=2,x=5solve and substitute back\begin{aligned} x+2y&=9,\qquad x-y=3 &&\text{simplify each equation}\\ x&=y+3 &&\text{rearrange the second}\\ (y+3)+2y&=9 &&\text{substitute into the first}\\ y&=2,\qquad x=5 &&\text{solve and substitute back} \end{aligned}

Why this step? Clearing a constant denominator changes every term in that equation; it creates no domain exclusion.

Answer. (x,y)=(5,2)(x,y)=(5,2).

Check. (5+4)/3=3(5+4)/3=3 and 2(5−2)=62(5-2)=6.

Elimination would work too. Choose the route with less algebra; no method has priority merely because of the order the equations are printed. A variable denominator, unlike the constant 33, would need a non-zero restriction retained throughout.

Watch out

Wrong: replace −y-y by −2x−1-2x-1 when y=2x−1y=2x-1. The correct substitution is −(2x−1)=−2x+1-(2x-1)=-2x+1.

Clear the fraction and use the equation that makes a subject easily.

Linear and quadratic systems

The same substitution works when one equation is quadratic. The resulting one-variable quadratic may give two roots, each needing its own partner.

You already know

A product equal to zero gives alternative roots. Solve every real branch of the quadratic, then substitute each root into the linear equation.

A quadratic in two unknowns may contain x2x^2, xyxy or y2y^2. It need not already look like y=ax2+bx+cy=ax^2+bx+c.

Worked example 5: a line and a sum of squares

Question. Solve y=x+1y=x+1 and x2+y2=5x^2+y^2=5.

Plan. Replace yy, solve the quadratic in xx, then pair each root with its own yy.

x2+(x+1)2=5substitute the whole expression2x2+2x−4=0expand and collect(x+2)(x−1)=0divide by 2 and factorisex=1⇒y=2first pairx=−2⇒y=−1second pair\begin{aligned} x^2+(x+1)^2&=5 &&\text{substitute the whole expression}\\ 2x^2+2x-4&=0 &&\text{expand and collect}\\ (x+2)(x-1)&=0 &&\text{divide by 2 and factorise}\\ x=1&\Rightarrow y=2 &&\text{first pair}\\ x=-2&\Rightarrow y=-1 &&\text{second pair} \end{aligned}

Why this step? The roots are alternatives; values from different branches cannot be mixed into new pairs.

Answer. (1,2)(1,2) and (−2,−1)(-2,-1).

Check. 12+22=51^2+2^2=5 and (−2)2+(−1)2=5(-2)^2+(-1)^2=5; both also satisfy the line.

Now change the quadratic's form to include a mixed xyxy term. The linear equation still supplies the substitution.

Worked example 6: a mixed quadratic term

Question. Solve x+y=4x+y=4 and 2xy+y2=122xy+y^2=12.

Plan. Write x=4−yx=4-y to leave a quadratic in yy.

2(4−y)y+y2=12substitute for xy2−8y+12=0expand and rearrange(y−2)(y−6)=0factorisey=2⇒x=2back-substitutey=6⇒x=−2keep the second branch\begin{aligned} 2(4-y)y+y^2&=12 &&\text{substitute for }x\\ y^2-8y+12&=0 &&\text{expand and rearrange}\\ (y-2)(y-6)&=0 &&\text{factorise}\\ y=2&\Rightarrow x=2 &&\text{back-substitute}\\ y=6&\Rightarrow x=-2 &&\text{keep the second branch} \end{aligned}

Why this step? Choosing x=4−yx=4-y keeps the square already in yy, so the expansion stays short.

Answer. (2,2)(2,2) and (−2,6)(-2,6).

Check. 2(2)(2)+22=122(2)(2)+2^2=12 and 2(−2)(6)+62=122(-2)(6)+6^2=12; both pairs sum to 44.

A negative coordinate is allowed in an unrestricted algebra problem. Reject it only if a stated context or domain excludes it. Neither the substitution method nor these solution-pair rules are supplied on the formula sheet.

Watch out

Wrong: list x=1,−2x=1,-2 and y=2,−1y=2,-1 without making the pairing clear. Write (1,2),(−2,−1)(1,2),(-2,-1), or explicitly connect each xx to its yy.

Try the sum-of-squares structure with a new line and new radius value.

Intersections and solution counts

A simultaneous solution is a common point of the two graphs. Count distinct common points, so a repeated quadratic root represents one intersection.

For the curve y=x2+1y=x^2+1 and line y=2x+cy=2x+c, substitution gives (x−1)2=c(x-1)^2=c. The picture shows how changing cc alters the number of intersections.

Three lines y=2x+c compared with y=x^2+1, showing two intersections, tangency and no intersection

At c=−1c=-1, a non-negative square would have to equal −1-1: there is no common point. The two graphs still exist, just as both opening equations exist without sharing a solution.

Worked example 7: two exact intersections

Question. Find the intersections of y=x2+1y=x^2+1 and y=2x+1y=2x+1.

Plan. Equate the outputs, solve for xx and recover the common heights.

x2+1=2x+1same y at an intersectionx(x−2)=0collect and factorisex=0⇒y=1first pointx=2⇒y=5second point\begin{aligned} x^2+1&=2x+1 &&\text{same }y\text{ at an intersection}\\ x(x-2)&=0 &&\text{collect and factorise}\\ x=0&\Rightarrow y=1 &&\text{first point}\\ x=2&\Rightarrow y=5 &&\text{second point} \end{aligned}

Why this step? Equating the two outputs finds exactly the horizontal coordinates where both graphs agree.

Answer. (0,1)(0,1) and (2,5)(2,5).

Check. The plotted crossings match; 02+1=10^2+1=1 and 22+1=52^2+1=5.

Change only the line's constant, from 11 to 00. The two intersection points now merge.

Worked example 8: one distinct intersection

Question. Determine the intersection of y=x2+1y=x^2+1 and y=2xy=2x.

Plan. Complete the square after equating the outputs.

x2+1=2xequate outputs(x−1)2=0rearrange as a squarex=1,y=2one distinct root and its partner\begin{aligned} x^2+1&=2x &&\text{equate outputs}\\ (x-1)^2&=0 &&\text{rearrange as a square}\\ x&=1,\qquad y=2 &&\text{one distinct root and its partner} \end{aligned}

Why this step? A square equals zero only when its base is zero. The repeated root gives one common point, where the line touches the curve.

Answer. One intersection, (1,2)(1,2).

Check. Both equations give height 22 at x=1x=1; the square is positive at every other xx.

More generally, (x−1)2=c(x-1)^2=c has two roots for c>0c>0, one for c=0c=0, and none for c<0c<0. This classification is not in the formula sheet: learn the reasoning. For a restricted domain, discard intersections outside it and retain allowed endpoints.

Exam tip

A calculator sketch can suggest tangency. To determine it, show a repeated root or an equivalent exact argument; apparent touching at screen resolution is not enough.

Vary the curve's constant and make the complete classification yourself.

Quick Recap

  • Eliminate matching coefficients, or substitute an equal expression.
  • Clear constant denominators across whole equations; keep variable-denominator restrictions.
  • A quadratic can supply two branches: recover and check each ordered pair.
  • Intersections correspond to common solutions; repeated roots count once.

Yes, both opening equations are valid yet have no common solution: their parallel lines demand different values for the same expression. A line and a quadratic can instead have zero, one or two common points.