4.4 - Constitutional protection of rights
An entrenched right is more secure than a promise that an ordinary majority may withdraw. Learn how the original Constitution, the Bill of Rights, later amendments and Supreme Court rulings protect Americans, and why protection on paper and protection in practice can differ.
Liberties, rights and entrenchment
Civil liberties protect freedom from unjustified government interference, such as the ability to express political views. Civil rights concern equal legal treatment and participation, such as freedom from racial discrimination in voting. The categories overlap: an equal right to protest involves both freedom and equality.
Constitutional rights
Rights protected by the Constitution, which places legal limits on ordinary governmental action and legislation.
The Constitution is entrenched: Article V makes changing its text substantially harder than passing an ordinary Act of Congress. A government cannot repeal a constitutional protection by a simple legislative majority. Courts can enforce the superior rule through judicial review. Entrenchment protects the text; it does not freeze every interpretation judges have ever given it.
Some protections appear in the original Constitution. Article I restricts suspension of habeas corpus, the procedure for challenging unlawful detention, except in specified emergencies. It prohibits bills of attainder, legislative punishment without a judicial trial, and ex post facto criminal laws. Article III provides jury trial for federal crimes, apart from impeachment; Article VI prohibits religious tests for federal public office. Original constitutional text.
If you sit in 2027: Issue 3's lower-case “constitution” in some key terms and Issue 4's “Constitution” refer to the same document; no rights are added by this stylistic correction.
The Bill of Rights
The first ten amendments, ratified in 1791, form the Bill of Rights. They address the danger that a powerful national government could threaten individual freedom.
| Amendment | Protection relevant to political analysis |
|---|---|
| First | Religion, speech, press, peaceful assembly and petitioning government |
| Second | Keeping and bearing arms, with its meaning developed through judgments |
| Fourth | Protection against unreasonable searches and seizures |
| Fifth | Due process, protection against compelled self-incrimination and double jeopardy; safeguards concerning takings of property |
| Sixth | Criminal-trial safeguards including a speedy public trial, an impartial jury and assistance of counsel |
| Eighth | Limits on excessive bail/fines and cruel and unusual punishment |
| Ninth | Listing some rights does not deny other rights retained by the people |
| Tenth | Powers not delegated to the United States, or prohibited to states, are reserved to states or the people |
The Third Amendment limits the quartering of soldiers, while the Seventh addresses juries in federal civil cases. A list of guarantees is not a list of absolute permissions. Courts determine the scope of protections and whether a particular restriction is lawful. Bill of Rights text.
These amendments originally constrained the federal government. Much of their protection has since been applied to states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Do not assume the Tenth Amendment gives states permission to violate individual constitutional rights; reserved powers operate within the wider Constitution.
Later amendments and equality
Later amendments transformed who could claim protection and participate politically. The Reconstruction amendments followed the Civil War. The Thirteenth Amendment (1865) prohibited slavery and involuntary servitude, except punishment following criminal conviction. The Fourteenth (1868) established citizenship rules and prohibited states from denying persons due process or equal protection. The Fifteenth (1870) prohibited denial of voting rights on grounds of race, colour or previous condition of servitude.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account