The Joy Luck Club: An-mei and Rose: Voice, Marriage and Choice
An-mei and Rose learn that silence can leave decisions to other people. Explore how Rose turns inherited warnings into a different way of acting.
A four-chapter inheritance
The Hsu story is scattered across all four parts of The Joy Luck Club. The chapters are not a simple family history told from earliest event to latest. Tan lets Rose's American marriage reach crisis before "Magpies" reveals the fuller history behind An-mei's advice.
| Chapter | Immediate situation | Contribution to the Hsu pattern |
|---|---|---|
| "Scar" | An-mei remembers her mother's return and sacrifice for the dying Popo. | A child learns that the family's condemning account of her mother is incomplete. |
| "Half and Half" | Rose connects Bing's drowning, An-mei's uncertain faith and the deterioration of her marriage. | Grief and guilt help explain why deciding feels dangerous. |
| "Without Wood" | Rose faces divorce papers, conflicting advice and Ted's claim on the house. | She moves from letting others define events to stating a boundary of her own. |
| "Magpies" | An-mei tells the fuller story of her mother's life and death in Wu Tsing's household. | A late revelation explains the cost behind An-mei's insistence that Rose speak. |
In this pattern, voice is more than talking. It is the ability to form and express a judgement that can alter who sets the terms of a relationship. Silence is not always cowardice: it may be imposed, learned, protective or caused by trauma. Yet silence can still have consequences. If Rose says that she cannot choose, Ted's choices continue to govern the marriage.
This gives the lesson a provisional interpretation: An-mei does not hand Rose a finished answer. She passes on knowledge about what silence costs, and Rose must decide how to use it in different circumstances.
Scar, faith and indecision
In "Scar", young An-mei first knows her absent mother through Popo's condemnation. The mother has been made a warning before An-mei is able to hear her version of events. When she returns to the dying Popo, however, her bodily sacrifice for a traditional remedy complicates that judgement. The woman whom the household has treated as disgraceful acts with extreme care towards the mother who rejected her.
The episode does not prove that suffering makes a woman noble, or that bodily sacrifice should be admired without question. Its sharper significance is that An-mei learns to distrust a family story that has denied her mother authority. Care has to be communicated through the body partly because the mother has so little accepted voice within the family.
"Half and Half" moves the problem into Rose's life. Early in her marriage, Rose lets Ted make decisions and experiences his certainty as protection. As that arrangement changes, he pushes responsibility towards her and then treats her indecision as a failure. Their supposed division of roles has never taught Rose how to voice a different judgement.
The memory of Bing's drowning gives this fear a deeper source. Rose had been made responsible for watching her brothers, saw danger too late and carries guilt after Bing disappears. One defensible reading is that the tragedy teaches her to associate responsibility with catastrophic error: if choosing can cause harm, allowing someone else to choose may feel safer. That explains her avoidance without excusing the unequal marital arrangement or blaming her for Ted's conduct.
An-mei's Bible resists a neat answer about faith. Bing's name is entered under deaths in erasable pencil, holding acknowledgement and refusal of finality together. Rose connects fate to expectation and inattention, then considers how faith takes over after loss. She is not simply fatalistic; she painfully recognises that noticing danger without acting does not prevent it.
The two chapters therefore establish an inheritance of incomplete voices:
- An-mei learns that other people can define a silenced woman's value.
- Rose learns to fear the consequences of her own judgement.
- Both experiences make An-mei's later warning urgent, but they do not make mother and daughter identical.
An-mei recalls how Popo spoke about her absent mother.
Source A
The Joy Luck Club — “Scar”
By Amy Tan
[1] When I was a young girl in China, my grandmother told me my mother was a ghost. This did not mean my mother was dead. In those days, a ghost was anything we were forbidden to talk about. So I knew Popo wanted me to forget my mother on purpose, and this is how I came to remember nothing of her. The life that I knew began in the large house in Ningpo with the cold hallways and tall stairs. This was my uncle and auntie’s family house, where I lived with Popo and my little brother.
[2] But I often heard stories of a ghost who tried to take children away, especially strong-willed little girls who were disobedient. Many times Popo said aloud to all who could hear that my brother and I had fallen out of the bowels of a stupid goose, two eggs that nobody wanted, not even good enough to crack over rice porridge. She said this so that the ghosts would not steal us away. So you see, to Popo we were also very precious.
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
An-mei watches her mother caring for the dying Popo.
Source B
The Joy Luck Club — “Scar”
By Amy Tan
[44] I worshipped this mother from my dream. But the woman standing by Popo’s bed was not the mother of my memory. Yet I came to love this mother as well. Not because she came to me and begged me to forgive her. She did not. She did not need to explain that Popo chased her out of the house when I was dying. This I knew. She did not need to tell me she married Wu Tsing to exchange one unhappiness for another. I knew this as well.
[45] Here is how I came to love my mother. How I saw in her my own true nature. What was beneath my skin. Inside my bones.
[46] It was late at night when I went to Popo’s room. My auntie said it was Popo’s dying time and I must show respect. I put on a clean dress and stood between my auntie and uncle at the foot of Popo’s bed. I cried a little, not too loud.
[47] I saw my mother on the other side of the room. Quiet and sad. She was cooking a soup, pouring herbs and medicines into the steaming pot. And then I saw her pull up her sleeve and pull out a sharp knife. She put this knife on the softest part of her arm. I tried to close my eyes, but could not.
[48] And then my mother cut a piece of meat from her arm. Tears poured from her face and blood spilled to the floor.
[49] My mother took her flesh and put it in the soup. She cooked magic in the ancient tradition to try to cure her mother this one last time. She opened Popo’s mouth, already too tight from trying to keep her spirit in. She fed her this soup, but that night Popo flew away with her illness.
[50] Even though I was young, I could see the pain of the flesh and the worth of the pain.
[51] This is how a daughter honors her mother. It is shou so deep it is in your bones. The pain of the flesh is nothing. The pain you must forget. Because sometimes that is the only way to remember what is in your bones. You must peel off your skin, and that of your mother, and her mother before her. Until there is nothing. No scar, no skin, no flesh.
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
Rose recalls the search after her younger brother Bing fell into the sea.
Source C
The Joy Luck Club — “Half and Half”
By Amy Tan
[61] Shouts erupt. Someone has thrown sand in Luke’s face and he’s jumped out of his sand grave and thrown himself on top of Mark, thrashing and kicking. My mother shouts for me to stop them. And right after I pull Luke off Mark, I look up and see Bing walking alone to the edge of the reef. In the confusion of the fight, nobody notices. I am the only one who sees what Bing is doing.
[62] Bing walks one, two, three steps. His little body is moving so quickly, as if he spotted something wonderful by the water’s edge. And I think, He’s going to fall in. I’m expecting it. And just as I think this, his feet are already in the air, in a moment of balance, before he splashes into the sea and disappears without leaving so much as a ripple in the water.
Section break.
[63] I sank to my knees watching that spot where he disappeared, not moving, not saying anything. I couldn’t make sense of it. I was thinking, Should I run to the water and try to pull him out? Should I shout to my father? Can I rise on my legs fast enough? Can I take it all back and forbid Bing from joining my father on the ledge?
[64] And then my sisters were back, and one of them said, “Where’s Bing?” There was silence for a few seconds and then shouts and sand flying as everyone rushed past me toward the water’s edge. I stood there unable to move as my sisters looked by the cove wall, as my brothers scrambled to see what lay behind pieces of driftwood. My mother and father were trying to part the waves with their hands.
[65] We were there for many hours. I remember the search boats and the sunset when dusk came. I had never seen a sunset like that: a bright orange flame touching the water’s edge and then fanning out, warming the sea. When it became dark, the boats turned their yellow orbs on and bounced up and down on the dark shiny water.
[66] As I look back, it seems unnatural to think about the colors of the sunset and boats at a time like that. But we all had strange thoughts. My father was calculating minutes, estimating the temperature of the water, readjusting his estimate of when Bing fell. My sisters were calling, “Bing! Bing!” as if he were hiding in some bushes high above the beach cliffs. My brothers sat in the car, quietly reading comic books. And when the boats turned off their yellow orbs, my mother went for a swim. She had never swum a stroke in her life, but her faith in her own nengkan convinced her that what these Americans couldn’t do, she could. She could find Bing.
[67] And when the rescue people finally pulled her out of the water, she still had her nengkan intact. Her hair, her clothes, they were all heavy with the cold water, but she stood quietly, calm and regal as a mermaid queen who had just arrived out of the sea. The police called off the search, put us all in our car, and sent us home to grieve.
Section break.
[68] I had expected to be beaten to death, by my father, by my mother, by my sisters and brothers. I knew it was my fault. I hadn’t watched him closely enough, and yet I saw him. But as we sat in the dark living room, I heard them, one by one whispering their regrets.
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
Without Wood and spoken choice
By "Without Wood", Rose's marriage is ending, but she still struggles to say what the ending means. She gives different accounts to friends and to her psychiatrist, absorbs competing advice and leaves Ted's papers unanswered. The problem is not a shortage of words. It is that other people's explanations crowd out her own judgement.
An-mei describes Rose as lacking the firmness of wood: she bends towards whichever person is speaking. The image is useful because it names a pattern, not a permanent identity. Rose can recognise that she has been shaped by other voices without accepting that she must remain shapeless.
Ted attempts to control both the speed of the divorce and possession of the house. Rose's eventual action is limited but decisive: she does not sign on his timetable or agree to disappear from the property. In the neglected garden, she states that she will remain. Her voice matters because it changes who is allowed to define the settlement.
The garden should not become a one-word symbol with a fixed answer. Its neglect can make visible what has happened to Rose's agency while Ted has stopped caring for both garden and marriage. Its uncontrolled growth may also suggest that a life not organised by Ted can look disorderly before it becomes self-directed. Neither reading proves that the marriage will recover.
Compare plot summary with interpretation:
| Plot statement | Interpretive development |
|---|---|
| Rose does not answer the divorce papers at first. | Her inaction leaves Ted's timetable and assumptions unchallenged, so silence helps preserve his control. |
| Rose refuses to leave the house. | Voice becomes a boundary: she does not need to save the marriage in order to claim a say in how it ends. |
| The garden is overgrown. | The changed space supports a reading of neglected agency and new, not-yet-ordered growth; it does not guarantee renewal. |
The strongest evidence for Rose's change is therefore not that she suddenly becomes fearless. It is that she acts while the outcome remains uncertain. Choice means accepting responsibility for a position, not knowing in advance that it will succeed.
Rose looks back at decision-making in her marriage to Ted.
Source A
The Joy Luck Club — “Half and Half”
By Amy Tan
[22] Over the years, Ted decided where we went on vacation. He decided what new furniture we should buy. He decided we should wait until we moved into a better neighborhood before having children. We used to discuss some of these matters, but we both knew the question would boil down to my saying, “Ted, you decide.” After a while, there were no more discussions. Ted simply decided. And I never thought of objecting. I preferred to ignore the world around me, obsessing only over what was in front of me: my T-square, my X-acto knife, my blue pencil.
[23] But last year Ted’s feelings about what he called “decision and responsibility” changed. A new patient had come to him asking what she could do about the spidery veins on her cheeks. And when he told her he could suck the red veins out and make her beautiful again, she believed him. But instead, he accidentally sucked a nerve out, and the left side of her smile fell down and she sued him.
[24] After he lost the malpractice lawsuit—his first, and a big shock to him I now realize—he started pushing me to make decisions. Did I think we should buy an American car or a Japanese car? Should we change from whole-life to term insurance? What did I think about that candidate who supported the contras? What about a family?
[25] I thought about things, the pros and the cons. But in the end I would be so confused, because I never believed there was ever any one right answer, yet there were many wrong ones. So whenever I said, “You decide,” or “I don’t care,” or “Either way is fine with me,” Ted would say in his impatient voice, “No, you decide. You can’t have it both ways, none of the responsibility, none of the blame.”
[26] I could feel things changing between us. A protective veil had been lifted and Ted now started pushing me about everything. He asked me to decide on the most trivial matters, as if he were baiting me. Italian food or Thai. One appetizer or two. Which appetizer. Credit card or cash. Visa or MasterCard.
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
An-mei speaks to Rose about the difficulties in her marriage.
Source B
The Joy Luck Club — “Without Wood”
By Amy Tan
[69] “Too busy for mother?”
[70] “I have an appointment . . . with my psychiatrist.”
[71] She was quiet for a while. “Why do you not speak up for yourself?” she finally said in her pained voice. “Why can you not talk to your husband?”
[72] “Ma,” I said, feeling drained. “Please. Don’t tell me to save my marriage anymore. It’s hard enough as it is.”
[73] “I am not telling you to save your marriage,” she protested. “I only say you should speak up.”
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
Ted has demanded the divorce papers and the house. Rose speaks to him in the garden.
Source C
The Joy Luck Club — “Without Wood”
By Amy Tan
[97] Ted was picking up plums from the ground and tossing them over the fence into the neighbor’s yard. “Where are the papers?” he finally said.
[98] I handed them to him and he stuffed them in the inside pocket of his jacket. He faced me and I saw his eyes, the look I had once mistaken for kindness and protection. “You don’t have to move out right away,” he said. “I know you’ll want at least a month to find a place.”
[99] “I’ve already found a place,” I said quickly, because right then I knew where I was going to live. His eyebrows raised in surprise and he smiled—for the briefest moment—until I said, “Here.”
[100] “What’s that?” he said sharply. His eyebrows were still up, but now there was no smile.
[101] “I said I’m staying here,” I announced again.
[102] “Who says?” He folded his arms across his chest, squinted his eyes, examining my face as if he knew it would crack at any moment. That expression of his used to terrify me into stammers.
[103] Now I felt nothing, no fear, no anger. “I say I’m staying, and my lawyer will too, once we serve you the papers,” I said.
[104] Ted pulled out the divorce papers and stared at them. His x’s were still there, the blanks were still blank. “What do you think you’re doing? Exactly what?” he said.
[105] And the answer, the one that was important above everything else, ran through my body and fell from my lips: “You can’t just pull me out of your life and throw me away.”
[106] I saw what I wanted: his eyes, confused, then scared. He was hulihudu. The power of my words was that strong.
Notes
Paragraph numbers locate the passage within this chapter. “Section break” marks a break in the original.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account