Klara and the Sun: Planning a Store-to-Yard Essay
A useful essay plan makes each selected episode change the argument. Build a flexible route through Klara’s life, with context attached to the interpretations it sharpens.
Turn a focus into an argument
Section C can centre on a character, a relationship or an idea. The focus changes what the same event is evidence for.
| Focus type | The planning question beneath it | Example of a useful tension |
|---|---|---|
| Character | What changes, persists or remains contradictory about this person? | Klara gains trust and responsibility, yet her status remains tied to usefulness. |
| Relationship | How do closeness, dependence or power develop between two characters? | Klara and Josie share genuine care inside a relationship created by purchase. |
| Idea | Where is the idea established, tested and complicated? | Replacement looks technically imaginable, but the novel questions whether a person is only reproducible information. |
Under Pearson's current Issue 3 Option B route, the eventual Section C response is marked through AO1 and AO4, equally weighted within one holistic mark out of 40. AO1 needs a critical, personally engaged whole-text interpretation supported by relevant examples. AO4 needs context that clarifies that interpretation. AO2 is not assessed: a comment on viewpoint or structure may help explain meaning, but method terminology earns no separate credit.
A provisional thesis is the plan's steering judgement. It should do three jobs:
- answer the exact focus;
- indicate development or tension across the novel;
- remain open to a defensible qualification.
Consider the idea-led focus Klara's usefulness. A thin starting claim would be: “Klara is useful because she helps Josie.” It is relevant, but it neither travels across the text nor leaves anything to test.
Here is the planning think-aloud:
- At the store: Klara is valued as a product that can be selected.
- At Josie's home: she becomes a trusted observer and carer, so usefulness appears to create personal value.
- At the Yard: she retains memories and satisfaction, but the family no longer needs her.
- Tension: usefulness enables intimacy and service while also making Klara disposable.
That thinking produces a more useful provisional thesis:
Across the novel, Klara's value seems to grow from selected product to trusted carer, yet the Yard suggests that human recognition remains tied to her usefulness. However, her own satisfaction in having served Josie prevents the ending from being only a story of exploitation.
This is not the only valid thesis. A learner could place greater weight on Klara's agency, on the sincerity of the family's affection, or on the injustice of purchased care. The requirement is a defensible line that can be tested, not one compulsory interpretation.
The selections move from the store to Capaldi’s proposal and the Yard.
Source A
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] The Mother considered this. Then she said, ‘Well, Klara. Since you appear to know so much about it. Will you please reproduce for me Josie’s walk? Will you do that for me? Right now? My daughter’s walk?’
[2] Behind the Mother’s shoulder, I saw Manager’s lips part, as though about to speak. But she said nothing. Instead, meeting my gaze, she gave me the smallest of nods.
[3] So I started to walk. I realized that, as well as the Mother – and of course Josie – the whole store was now watching and listening. I stepped beneath the arch, onto the Sun’s patterns spread across the floor. Then I went in the direction of the B3s standing mid-store, and the Glass Display Trolley. I did all I could to reproduce Josie’s walk just as I’d seen it, that first time after she’d got out of the taxi, when Rosa and I were in the window, then four days later, when she’d come towards the window after the Mother had removed her hand from her shoulder, then finally as I’d seen her a moment ago, hurrying to me with relieved happiness in her eyes.
[4] When I reached the Glass Display Trolley I started to go around it, taking care not to lose the character of Josie’s walk even as I tried not to brush against the boy B3 standing beside the trolley.
[5] But as I was about to start on the return lap, I glanced up and caught sight of the Mother, and something in what I saw made me stop. She was still watching me carefully, but it was as if her gaze was now focused straight through me, as if I was the glass in the window and she was trying to see something a long way behind it. I remained there beside the Glass Display Trolley, one foot poised, heel off the floor, and there was a strange stillness in the store. Then Manager said:
[6] ‘As you see, Klara has extraordinary observational ability. I’ve never known one like her.’
[7] ‘Mom.’ This time Josie’s voice was hushed. ‘Mom. Please.’
[8] ‘Very well. We’ll take her.’
[9] Josie came hurrying to me. She put her arms around me and held me. When I gazed over the child’s head, I saw Manager smiling happily, and the Mother, her face drawn and serious, looking down to search in her shoulder bag.
Notes
Part One. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Source B
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] I thought when I first came here that the Yard was untidy, but I’ve now come to appreciate its good order. The initial impression, I realized, was due to many of the objects here having in themselves an untidy identity – with the remains of severed cables protruding or with dented grille panels. On closer observation it becomes clear how hard the yardmen have worked to place each piece of machinery, crate or bundle into orderly rows, so that a visitor walking down the long passages that have been created in this way – even if that visitor must be careful not to trip on a rod or wire – will be able to take in the objects one by one.
[2] Because of the wide sky and lack of tall objects, I become quickly aware of any visitors in the Yard. I spot their figures even if they are far in the distance and only small shapes moving among the rows. But visitors aren’t frequent, and when I hear human voices, they most often belong to the yardmen calling to each other.
Notes
Part Six. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Source C
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] ‘Then tell me, Klara. Have you all this time – until you came here, I mean – have you all this time been with the people you went to from the store? Forgive my asking, but I no longer have easy access to such information.’
[2] ‘Yes, of course. I was with Josie all the time. Until she went to college.’
[3] ‘So it was successful. A successful home.’
[4] ‘Yes. I believe I gave good service and prevented Josie from becoming lonely.’
Notes
Part Six. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Select a lifecycle route
Whole-text planning does not mean squeezing every incident into the response. It means selecting evidence so that selected stages develop the argument across the novel.
| Lifecycle stage | Discriminating event cluster | What the cluster can test |
|---|---|---|
| Part One: store and selection | Window observation, solar dependence, the Beggar Man episode and Josie's eventual selection of Klara | Product status, observation, faith, care inside commerce |
| Part Two: entry into Josie's world | The home, interaction meeting and Klara's imitation of Josie at Morgan's Falls | Belonging, social hierarchy, performance, the first possibility of replacement |
| Part Three: illness, exclusion and petition | Josie's decline, Rick's exclusion from lifted privilege and Klara's first barn appeal | Service becoming action, unequal opportunity, faith under pressure |
| Part Four: continuation and sacrifice | Capaldi's artificial continuation plan and the removal of P-E-G Nine | Personhood as reproducible data, instrumental use, bodily cost |
| Part Five: crisis and recovery | The second appeal, sunlight in Josie's room and Josie's recovery | Hope and uncertain causation, changing dependence on Klara |
| Part Six: separation and Yard | Josie's college future, divergence from Rick, reduced need for Klara, refusal of Capaldi's research request and the Manager's Yard visit | Fulfilment, relational uniqueness, redundancy, memory and abandonment |
The event names are retrieval cues, not ready-made analysis. A scene becomes useful only when the plan states what it establishes or changes.
For the model focus on usefulness, four clusters can account for all six Parts:
- Part One - selected: Klara's care and attention distinguish her, but her value is still judged in a marketplace.
- Parts Two and Three - trusted and tested: observation, imitation and the first barn petition make her increasingly important, while her outsider status and service role remain visible.
- Parts Four and Five - used at greatest cost: the continuation plan and loss of P-E-G Nine extend usefulness from companionship towards replacement and self-sacrifice; recovery then reduces the need that gave her this importance.
- Part Six - remembered after usefulness: the Yard exposes disposability, while Klara's retrospective satisfaction preserves a different measure of value.
This is a route through the evidence, not a fixed number of paragraphs. A thematic plan might return to the Yard earlier as a lens on selection; a chronological plan might pair Parts differently. Both can succeed when the selected range supports whole-novel understanding and each move develops the judgement; there is no requirement to mention every Part.
Source A
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] ‘Why would I be gone?’ I said quietly. ‘We made a promise.’
[2] ‘Yeah,’ Josie said. ‘Yeah, I guess we did. I guess I was the one who screwed up. I mean taking so long.’
[3] As I smiled at her, she called over her shoulder: ‘Mom! This is her! The one I’ve been looking for!’
[4] The Mother came slowly towards the arch, then stopped. And for a moment, all three were looking at me: Josie at the front, beaming happily; Manager, just behind her, also smiling, but with a caution in her look which I took as an important signal from her; and then the Mother, her eyes narrowed like people on the sidewalk when they’re trying to see if a taxi is free or already taken. And when I saw her and the way she was looking at me, the fear – the one that had all but vanished when Josie had cried, ‘You’re still here!’ – came back into my mind.
[5] ‘I didn’t mean to take so long,’ Josie was saying. ‘But I got a little sick. I’m fine again though.’ Then she called back: ‘Mom? Can we buy her right away? Before someone else comes in and takes her?’
Notes
Part One. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Source B
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] I thought when I first came here that the Yard was untidy, but I’ve now come to appreciate its good order. The initial impression, I realized, was due to many of the objects here having in themselves an untidy identity – with the remains of severed cables protruding or with dented grille panels. On closer observation it becomes clear how hard the yardmen have worked to place each piece of machinery, crate or bundle into orderly rows, so that a visitor walking down the long passages that have been created in this way – even if that visitor must be careful not to trip on a rod or wire – will be able to take in the objects one by one.
[2] Because of the wide sky and lack of tall objects, I become quickly aware of any visitors in the Yard. I spot their figures even if they are far in the distance and only small shapes moving among the rows. But visitors aren’t frequent, and when I hear human voices, they most often belong to the yardmen calling to each other.
Notes
Part Six. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Source C
Klara and the Sun
By Kazuo Ishiguro
[1] ‘Then tell me, Klara. Have you all this time – until you came here, I mean – have you all this time been with the people you went to from the store? Forgive my asking, but I no longer have easy access to such information.’
[2] ‘Yes, of course. I was with Josie all the time. Until she went to college.’
[3] ‘So it was successful. A successful home.’
[4] ‘Yes. I believe I gave good service and prevented Josie from becoming lonely.’
Notes
Part Six. The numbers label the supplied paragraphs.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account