Great Expectations: Pip's Debts: Joe, Estella and Magwitch
Explore what Pip owes Joe, Estella and Magwitch. Dickens tests whether gratitude and love help Pip recognise other people beyond the roles he wants them to play.
Debts beyond money
Study all 59 chapters of Great Expectations: Chapters 1–19 form Stage One, 20–39 Stage Two and 40–59 Stage Three. Whole-text responses draw on this complete development.
In Great Expectations, a debt can be a sum to repay, but it can also describe a relationship that cannot be settled like an account. Four distinctions will keep the three relationships clear:
| Idea | Meaning in this lesson |
|---|---|
| Financial debt | Money that can, in principle, be calculated and repaid |
| Gratitude | Recognition of what another person has freely done |
| Moral obligation | A responsibility to respond with honesty, care or loyalty |
| Possessive claim | Treating another person's gift, love or identity as something one is entitled to control |
Joe, Estella and Magwitch place Pip under very different kinds of pressure. Joe gives care without demanding a return. Estella gives warnings that Pip does not want to hear, while he imagines her as the reward for becoming a gentleman. Magwitch gives Pip money and paternal devotion, but also tries to make Pip into proof of his own success. Pip's development depends on learning that these offers do not create the same kind of debt.
Joe's constancy and Pip's shame
Text
Great Expectations
By Charles Dickens
Chapter 27
[1] I had neither the good sense nor the good feeling to know that this was all my fault, and that if I had been easier with Joe, Joe would have been easier with me. I felt impatient of him and out of temper with him; in which condition he heaped coals of fire on my head.
Notes
Paragraph numbers identify this extract. Original spelling and dialect are retained.
Text
Great Expectations
By Charles Dickens
Chapter 27
[1] Our eyes met, and all the “Sir” melted out of that manly heart as he gave me his hand.
[2] “Pip, dear old chap, life is made of ever so many partings welded together, as I may say, and one man’s a blacksmith, and one’s a whitesmith, and one’s a goldsmith, and one’s a coppersmith. Diwisions among such must come, and must be met as they come. If there’s been any fault at all to-day, it’s mine. You and me is not two figures to be together in London; nor yet anywheres else but what is private, and beknown, and understood among friends. It ain’t that I am proud, but that I want to be right, as you shall never see me no more in these clothes. I’m wrong in these clothes. I’m wrong out of the forge, the kitchen, or off th’ meshes. You won’t find half so much fault in me if you think of me in my forge dress, with my hammer in my hand, or even my pipe. You won’t find half so much fault in me if, supposing as you should ever wish to see me, you come and put your head in at the forge window and see Joe the blacksmith, there, at the old anvil, in the old burnt apron, sticking to the old work. I’m awful dull, but I hope I’ve beat out something nigh the rights of this at last. And so GOD bless you, dear old Pip, old chap, GOD bless you!”
[3] I had not been mistaken in my fancy that there was a simple dignity in him. The fashion of his dress could no more come in its way when he spoke these words than it could come in its way in Heaven. He touched me gently on the forehead, and went out. As soon as I could recover myself sufficiently, I hurried out after him and looked for him in the neighbouring streets; but he was gone.
Notes
Paragraph numbers identify this extract. Original spelling and dialect are retained.
Text
Great Expectations
By Charles Dickens
Chapter 57
[1] At last, one day, I took courage, and said, “Is it Joe?”
[2] And the dear old home-voice answered, “Which it air, old chap.”
[3] “O Joe, you break my heart! Look angry at me, Joe. Strike me, Joe. Tell me of my ingratitude. Don’t be so good to me!”
[4] For Joe had actually laid his head down on the pillow at my side, and put his arm round my neck, in his joy that I knew him.
[5] “Which dear old Pip, old chap,” said Joe, “you and me was ever friends. And when you’re well enough to go out for a ride—what larks!”
[6] After which, Joe withdrew to the window, and stood with his back towards me, wiping his eyes. And as my extreme weakness prevented me from getting up and going to him, I lay there, penitently whispering, “O God bless him! O God bless this gentle Christian man!”
Notes
Paragraph numbers identify this extract. Original spelling and dialect are retained.
Joe's repeated phrase "Ever the best of friends" appears at widely separated points in Pip's life. Its wording stays simple and stable while Pip's judgement changes. The repetition therefore measures Pip more than Joe: Joe does not need to become loyal, but Pip needs to learn how badly he has misread loyalty.
Chapter 27 makes that misreading especially painful. Before Joe arrives in London, Pip admits that he anticipates the visit with embarrassment. During the visit, Joe's clothes, speech and awkwardness become objects of Pip's scrutiny. Yet the adult narrator states that Joe's unease was "all my fault". Retrospective narration lets the older Pip expose the younger Pip's class shame instead of asking the reader to share it.
A complete line of reasoning can move like this:
- Interpretation: Joe's constancy reveals that Pip's shame is a failure of judgement, not evidence that Joe lacks worth.
- Small evidence: "Ever the best of friends" returns across the novel, while Chapter 27 gives adult Pip's admission of fault.
- Consequential choice: structural repetition keeps Joe's commitment stable; retrospective narration changes how Pip's earlier behaviour is judged.
- Meaning: the contrast makes social embarrassment look morally ungentle.
- Development: in Chapter 57, after Joe nurses him and pays his debts, Pip calls Joe a "gentle Christian man". The adjective “gentle” revises Pip's earlier obsession with the social title “gentleman”.
Chapter 58 completes the distinction between money and gratitude. Pip can work to repay what Joe has paid on his behalf, but he recognises that no financial repayment could cancel the debt created by years of freely given care. His recognition is real, but late: it does not erase Joe's humiliation in London or restore their childhood household.
Estella and the limits of love
Text
Great Expectations
By Charles Dickens
Chapter 44
[1] I saw Miss Havisham put her hand to her heart and hold it there, as she sat looking by turns at Estella and at me.
[2] “It seems,” said Estella, very calmly, “that there are sentiments, fancies,—I don’t know how to call them,—which I am not able to comprehend. When you say you love me, I know what you mean, as a form of words; but nothing more. You address nothing in my breast, you touch nothing there. I don’t care for what you say at all. I have tried to warn you of this; now, have I not?”
[3] I said in a miserable manner, “Yes.”
[4] “Yes. But you would not be warned, for you thought I did not mean it. Now, did you not think so?”
[5] “I thought and hoped you could not mean it. You, so young, untried, and beautiful, Estella! Surely it is not in Nature.”
Notes
Paragraph numbers identify this extract. Original spelling and dialect are retained.
Text
Great Expectations
By Charles Dickens
Chapter 38
[1] Estella looked at her with perfect composure, and again looked down at the fire. Her graceful figure and her beautiful face expressed a self-possessed indifference to the wild heat of the other, that was almost cruel.
[2] “You stock and stone!” exclaimed Miss Havisham. “You cold, cold heart!”
[3] “What?” said Estella, preserving her attitude of indifference as she leaned against the great chimney-piece and only moving her eyes; “do you reproach me for being cold? You?”
[4] “Are you not?” was the fierce retort.
[5] “You should know,” said Estella. “I am what you have made me. Take all the praise, take all the blame; take all the success, take all the failure; in short, take me.”
[6] “O, look at her, look at her!” cried Miss Havisham, bitterly; “Look at her so hard and thankless, on the hearth where she was reared! Where I took her into this wretched breast when it was first bleeding from its stabs, and where I have lavished years of tenderness upon her!”
[7] “At least I was no party to the compact,” said Estella, “for if I could walk and speak, when it was made, it was as much as I could do. But what would you have? You have been very good to me, and I owe everything to you. What would you have?”
[8] “Love,” replied the other.
[9] “You have it.”
[10] “I have not,” said Miss Havisham.
[11] “Mother by adoption,” retorted Estella, never departing from the easy grace of her attitude, never raising her voice as the other did, never yielding either to anger or tenderness,—“mother by adoption, I have said that I owe everything to you. All I possess is freely yours. All that you have given me, is at your command to have again. Beyond that, I have nothing. And if you ask me to give you, what you never gave me, my gratitude and duty cannot do impossibilities.”
Notes
Paragraph numbers identify this extract. Original spelling and dialect are retained.
Estella's first insults at Satis House make Pip notice his "coarse hands" and "thick boots". The narrator says that her contempt becomes "infectious": Pip catches a judgement that he had not previously made about himself. His love for Estella is therefore entangled from the beginning with shame and the wish to become socially different.
That does not make Estella a simple cause of Pip's failures. Pip narrates her as the centre of his imagined future, but her direct speech repeatedly interrupts his fantasy. She warns him that she cannot return his love. In Chapter 44 she reminds him that she has tried to warn him and insists that marrying Drummle is her own act. The decision can be read as damaged, self-punishing or resistant, but Pip's love does not give him the right to choose for her.
Chapter 38 sharpens the distinction between gratitude and love. When Estella tells Miss Havisham, "I am what you have made me", she accepts the fact of her formation while refusing the demand to feel an affection she was trained against. Her controlled direct speech gives her a counter-voice: gratitude and duty may be owed, but love cannot be produced on command.
The same principle limits Pip. His pain can be sincere, and Estella can still cause harm, but neither fact turns her into a prize that loyalty should earn. A defensible interpretation should therefore hold two ideas together: Estella has been shaped by another person's design, yet she also warns, argues and makes constrained choices.
Continue this lesson.
You’re previewing NovaLearn without an account. Create a free account to read the rest.
Create free account